January six happens and she says something and now its like, youre out. Bolvar had the support of the relatively new nation of Haiti, and he visited that country twice. Sort of laughing at the excesses and not taking it incredibly seriously. And the the more in common data is both reassuring and not its reassuring in the sense that what it says is, look, the vast bulk of us are not in these polarized edges and extremes. My special favorite is one and you just heard some examples of this where theyre like, yes, things are so bad. What the leader does is the leader sets the course of a cultural river. Lets listen. And so therefore, what about them kind of justifies that, well, the left has people like this in their coalition, so we get to have people like this in our coalition. The American Revolution hoped to achieve Independence . Good standing. And you know, who does run the United States. Right? Maybe somebody could explain it to me a divorce from what? You literally wrote the book on the potential of a national divorce. The response was that cant be right. The main difference between the American and French Revoultion was that one successfully converted to a democratic government and one did not. Large billows of smoke blow into the sky. But if youre not exerting that as a force of will, you leave the field to the people who are deadly serious about this stuff. American Revolution, also called United States War of Independence or American Revolutionary War, (177583), insurrection by which 13 of Great Britains North American colonies won political independence and went on to form the United States of America. Mhmm. Let let Kelly sit. I dont see so much national divorce rhetoric coming from the left. This means that the French Revolution was a more recent event and was therefore influenced by the ideas and events of the American Revolution. Were like, well, in the beginning, I was for it. In 1777, French volunteers began arriving in support of the revolution, and in 1778 the French government officially allied itself with the new American country against the British. Enlightenment thinker, John Locke, contributed considerably to the growth of the U.S. by influencing the founders in their making of the constitution, which supported John Lockes and other Enlightenment thinkers ideas for government guidelines. I mean, its ridiculous the way its run right now. The French Revolution was a conflict rooted in envy with desperate peasants whipped into a frenzy. Okay. What is a revolution? But, like, We asked these Trump voters about the investigations into Trump and they dont think any of them are legitimate and they cant name anyone they would trust. Posted 2 years ago. Fill out the Skimming for Gist section of the Three Close Reads Worksheet as you complete your first close read. The French Revolution focused the same idea as Thomas Hobbes. And so these people including the women in the group are like, well, I would vote for a woman, but unfortunately, I dont think other people would or I think world leaders wouldnt take them seriously because of how these other countries are. And so theres this absolute unwillingness to sort of say this is so far beyond the pale that Im gonna break with this kind of core sense of identity that I have. For the vast, vast, vast, vast majority of Republicans. Although the Civil War and American Revolution shared many similarities, the Civil War differed in the fact that it was more of a confrontation of two opposing. Thats right. They both had a time when both sides oppressed the French and British government. Shes wrong about everything. Overview: In this lesson, students will analyze primary and secondary sources using the OPTIC strategy. The french did not have much of a trained army its was more of a rebellion of a certain class of people because not all classes of people supported the french revolution. Theyre passive participants and commentators about events that theyre not in control of that theyre not gonna exert their will over one way or the other. Okay. To change the laws, the king called a representative body known as the Estates General in 1788. The revolutions however also had some similarities but ultimately are overruled by their variances, The main alteration being the reason for PDF. Trump broke you. Yeah. And in fact, one of the things that sort of saved us from that group its not all been in one party. We know trust is the problem. And one of my big concerns is The minority of Americans who are extremely activated politically are extremely polarized and hate each other very much. And people can do it for a while. The purpose was to scare people to support the revolution or they would die. Our focus grew to have some thoughts. New York Times opinion columnist David French (literally) wrote the book on a possible national divorce. The leadership in both countries at the time of their revolutions was certainly repressive, especially in terms of taxation. This is ridiculous. Revolutionary leaders established new countries that only sometimes lived up to promises of democratic rule. They insisted on the implementation of new measures that would guarantee the natural rights of all citizens and believed that, as Rousseau wrote, no man has any natural authority over his fellow men, and since force is not the source of right, conventions remain as the basis of all lawful authority among men. . Now, theres no real condemnation to it. The American and French Revolution are both remembered in history as two major changes that would shape what we know today. In the early stages of the rebellion by the American colonists, most of them still saw themselves as English subjects who were being denied their rights as such. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices. Also the French Revolution consisted of a lot more violence than the American Revolution. I mean, she definitely appeals to that super far right group and guests who have a coach for him, Georgia. In other words, the way that you deal with the dissent and debate in profound disagreements in what he calls like the danger or the violence of faction is not by trying to suppress factions. This is a great way to get students to think in depth and compare and contrast the American Revolution, French Revolution, and Russian Revolutions.The worksheet is sold separately and its called: World History: Comparing American, French, and Russian Revolutions This is an extension to another assignment that only compares the American and French And now you can talk, but Im so bad about this. Composed of seven states from the South, this new government looked to separate from a union that they felt was tipping in power towards those who wanted to threaten the rights of the South, especially slavery. Compare And Contrast The American Revolution Vs French Revolution. What has. And they would have been part of that old coalition, and theyre different now. Its pretty much like in good faith But because theyre pouring Fox News and the daily wire and other right wing sources into their ears, they dont have that much context, and they do think that Fox is the most trustworthy, and its all the other people who are wrong, look, people are responsible for their own actions, responsible for things, but they Im most had been poisoned slowly by these institutions. And Ive had the same conversation with folks who say, well, I go first to fox, and then I also look at CNN. Militias, poorly disciplined and with elected officers, were summoned for periods usually not exceeding three months. But like for the most part, they were decent people who recognized, like, that Trump is bad. The main difference between the American and French Revoultion was that one successfully converted to a democratic government and one did not. But before I do that since you brought it up, I wanna hit this set. But guess what? Yeah. Well. Both revolutions followed the anatomy of a revolution and had comparable causes, however the French Revolution politically better outcomes, whereas the Latin American Revolution resulted in poverty and lost territory. The French Revolution was fought by lower and middle class, and peasants. He was a brilliant general who defeated Napoleon's attempt to regain French control over the colony. At any given time, however, the American forces seldom numbered over 20,000; in 1781 there were only about 29,000 insurgents under arms throughout the country. Both countries have many differences and similarities, ranging from the individuals fighting these wars to tactics and strategies they used to win. Youre gonna be automatically dismissive. sooner rather than later, its getting very difficult to talk. In the northern regions of Latin America, the revolutionary general Simn Bolvar successfully fought Spanish forces and created a short-lived "Gran Columbia" between 1819 and 1830 that was modeled after the United States. Which one of these revolutions was the greatest in relevance to the listing of mankind rights? And thats enough in close states to really make all the difference. by. And you know, Id imagine youd get a little pushback on this idea that that theres not something endemic in the Republican Party. And they go far right, but same time, if theres something bad happening caused by the right, theyll call it out. We know a lot about that. If you're seeing this message, it means we're having trouble loading external resources on our website. Because I Will Saletan is it is not a one-sided thing. And that was that. Two revolutions, both taking place in the 18th Century, both world-changing. Many states continued to combine church and state. The Mexican Revolution for Independence lasted for 11 years from 1810-1821. The French were under a monarchy so the only option they had was to overthrow their king a create a republic. Lastly, both parties got power in the end from whom they wanted to be free from. The late 18th and 19th century brought about the French and Haitian Revolutions. The war followed more than a decade of growing estrangement between the British crown and a large and influential segment of its North American colonies that was caused by British attempts to assert greater control over colonial affairs after having long adhered to a policy of salutary neglect. No, its more secure. And in fact, If youre a typical Republican, you think the average Democrat is a lot more extreme than they are. To actively oppose it. From the beginning, sea power was vital in determining the course of the war, lending to British strategy a flexibility that helped compensate for the comparatively small numbers of troops sent to America and ultimately enabling the French to help bring about the final British surrender at Yorktown. This information is like the biggest word out there. Yeah. The debt from this huge war helped spark the American and French Revolutions. Quebec and Canada has had various referendum about secession and leaving. Pyramid, the tip of the infotainment spear saying, Arizona is lost and the people just said, no, I refuse. Even with both Revolution developing years apart they had very similar desires and obstacles to face. Of a national divorce, but I want to play you just as a setup here. Every child learns of the American Revolution at least once in their lives. And then, therefore, what that means is however far Trump goes or Marjorie Taylor Green goes, there appears to be no direction they can go that will put them actually truly beyond the pale. He was the Republican nominee in their Republicans. David, my friend, thank you for being here. I was like, this is such a good group for David French to watch. happened. They need to have a much more clear way to vote like it used to be. Suddenly, the Latin American colonies found themselves without a direct European power telling them what to do. Youll find more maybe more information on Facebook or social media, but youre not necessarily gonna get the truth either. And then it runs in to the new course of the river. Other countries also supported the Americans, including the Spanish and Dutch, who declared war on Great Britain in 1779 and 1780. Absolutely. Have no idea where to find the right answer. The Haitian Revolution established the second independent republic in the Americas and the first independent nation-state ruled by people of African descent. But at no point, theyre the sense of Well, thats just too far to be in our coalition. Thats the dynamic. I mean, if youre talking about in the millions, yes, but as a percentage of Americans, low. I do think that movements can be learning organisms. And then Fox tells them about MSNBC or CNN or whatever. Theres no such thing sort of historically as well. Although, can I just ask, what every time somebody brings up the national divorce, I know in your book, you kinda lay out two scenarios, one where Texas secedes, one where California secedes, but, like, national divorce doesnt make any sense? Within the next two years France would completely abolish the nobility and pass its own constitution, establishing a representative democracy. its not an insignificant part of the party. Sure. The years 1750-1900 are better known as the Revolution Era. The French Revolution was not successful in forming a democratic government due to France's history of a monarchy, economic issues and divison among its' people. However, the Civil War was a not a complete representation of a second American Revolution. Now well see. But right now, Sarah, were still in the world where anybody who stands up. Theyre a lot more commonality than we believe. We are not united. I would say that the actual number of people who really truly want a national divorce is very small, relatively small. Which one is most important in history when we aren't using the bias of America. Yeah. Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. Because these are the people who sort of know better, but theres no leader or anybody else who is appealing to the good nature thats inside of them that you hear coming out and is pulling on those best instincts to say we have to resist this. The French Revolution took place in France from 1789-1799. Oh, man. Every child learns of the American Revolution at least once in their lives. James OKeefe investigated and uncovered crimes of Donald Trump. The votes were all skewed in strange ways. Ironically, the transcription service has particular problems with the word bulwark, so you may see it mangled as Bullard, Boulart, or even bull word. Enjoy! Like, thats absurd. And David, Im sure you caught this. And so if youre talking about succession, what youre often talking about here, if youre looking at sort of historically, I mean, weve had various attempts. the fox scandal they may have. Shes there to fire up the the far right wingers. So this is my last question for you. I mean, its the hot air, you know, its coming. They both got their idea from Enlightenment thinkers. Because you do this thing at the beginning where everybody tells you, like, what they do for fun and, you know, where they live and what they did for work and, like, you know, just the sweetest room, she talks about your delicious grandchildren. I mean, being hawkish on Russia is a core right identity for a long, long time. This is actually from just some accumulated clips. I dont understand. This document declared the sovereignty of the American states and listed the natural rights of mankind. That there was a very troubling part about why Nikki Haley could not be the president, and it was super like well, no world leader would take a woman seriously. The American and French revolutions are similar in some ways but different in others. And so, like, talk about how critical leadership is because I thats in your book. So let me just hit you with a smattering of what we hear. Several horses and men are down. The Lensgreve (landgrave) of Hesse furnished approximately three-fifths of that total. Dont take that seriously. However, at the same time, and I actually wanna write about this, I think a lot of the folks who are saying, well, look, I mean, weve got blue cities and red states and got red areas and blue states. However, the Civil War was a not a complete representation of a second American Revolution. But the revolution soon turned more violent and radical as peasants attacked castles and burned records of their debts. Its like your a person has landed from another planet to tell you things that are completely outside of your zone of experience. In France, the lower classes overthrew the Old Regime. Civil war seems, you know. There were around 500,000 enslaved people living in Saint Domingue along with around 30,000 free people of color and 40,000 whites. It occurred between the years 1765 and 1783, resulting in a lot of bloodshed and casualties. It was a period of time when the people overthrow the government and took over to create a better leadership for the country. And so when you talk to somebody who liked those folks in the focus group, Its like peeling an onion of manufactured distrust. The idea of having one evil and selfish king had to change. Lets and hes a rhino. King Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette lived in Versailles far from the other forms of government, abusing the country wealth. Colorful drawings of soldiers In different colored uniforms holding heads on pikes. In the 18th Century the main problem the Army had was manpower. They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors. Now, why is that bad news? But the republic was short-lived. Oh, thats ridiculous. I actually had a whole section on Democrats that, like, we just dont even have time to get to. And you had a great piece. Though they received no formal training, they were not so dependent on a book knowledge of military tactics as were many of the Americans. In 1810, peasants in Mexico revolted because they wanted their own land and because food prices were too high. They revolted in response to events happening in Europe. Everyone, and welcome to the Focus Group podcast. In the instant they stand up, its what happened to so and so. The years 1750-1900 are better known as the Revolution Era. The similarity between them is that the citizens in both countries, both faced the block of common economical development of the government. It's not as if all revolutions challenged every issue. The sphere of liberty in the US is broad enough to wear a variety of communities can live side by side with each other. And so why wouldnt I vote for the Republican? You know, towards the end of your book, you lay out with what you call it James Madisons vision of pluralism. Churches controlled more affairs of the state. And its so hard to know where the truth is. The despot they had as a king was not treating everyone he ruled with fairness. If you missed it a couple weeks back, Margery Taylor Green tweeted, we need a national divorce. So long as their politicians remain Republican compared to the Democratic Party, which is just not an for them, period end discussion, no further conversation necessary. Similarly, in early 1775, colonists were preparing for revolution against a power that they felt oppressed their rights and wanted to take away their liberties. After French King Louis XVI was tried and executed on January 21, 1793, war between France and monarchal nations Great Britain and Spain was inevitable. This is where Right. View full question and answer details: https://www.wyzant.com/resources/answers/920758/compare-the-cause-and-outcomes-of-the-american-revolution-and-the-fren. I used to respect you. We should be able to get along. The British had come to Concord to seize the military stores of the colonists, who had been forewarned of the raid through efficient lines of communicationincluding the ride of Paul Revere, which is celebrated with poetic license in Longfellows Paul Reveres Ride (1861). At that time the remedy for this problem was drafting the poor, uneducated and less fortunate members of society. And, you know, one of the powers you wanna go back to our founding documents, for example, the statement that all men are created equal and endowed by their creator certain unalienable rights among them, life liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, was setting a cultural course for the United States that we were often contrary to, but had enormous power over the course of the next two centuries plus to where eventually we started to get more and more and more in conformity with that vision. It was backdated. One of the ships has been badly damaged, with all of its sails torn down. Finally, according N12 and KAN surveys, respectively, only 45% of those who voted for any of the coalition parties and only 36% of Likud voters are in favor of continuing with this judicial . As the ideas spread over the years American and French lives would change slowly. We know that the media feeds it. People heavily associate the French Revolution with the American Revolution, due to the many general similarities. This whole voting system is ridiculous. And who has the power? that is exactly how this group was. And the thing that I noticed I hear this a lot, actually, where people say, shes like, AOC. And unsurprisingly, the next section I have here is, lets listen to these voters talk the media. In general, the American Revolution was more successful than the French revolution. And then, of course, youre gonna be automatically mistrustful of it. Oh, which is exactly where we are. I mean, if you ask them about Merrick Garland, like, talk about someone whos tanking with them. And if you were going to go against that cultural tone on the right, it was exhausting. Also the types of people who fought in the revolutions differed. Ive seen the evidence of its crimes is the only reason I would agree with their decision. And the leadership is this key element to how you bring out the better angels of our nature. The causes of the revolutions in France and America were very similar. And so the direction that the river flows, whether its towards integrity, whether its towards compassion, etcetera, or whether its towards division, or towards anger, Its not that you cant defy the leader, but its exhausting and hard because youre swimming upstream. The French Revolution had the cause of starvation, and both the American and French Revolutions had the cause of unfair Taxes. Dont trust mail in and then Fox calls for Arizona, and the whole right wing population or much of it was like, wait, we were told not to trust this process, and theres Fox going ahead and calling this red state for Biden that cant possibly be real. The National Assembly ended the privileges of the nobles and ended feudalism in France. They both had a time when both sides oppressed the French and British government. The king backed down, but the country was now in revolt, not just in the cities but across the countryside. The numbers dont seem to add up. Both revolutions were connected to each other because of the link between France and Haiti, known then as St Domingue. This was not a universal sentiment towards secession. You know, like, I got preferences within the group, but, like, as long as they got that r, theyre gonna be better than what weve gotten. Yes Ma'am Resources. Yeah. The fundamentals of each revolution, why the citizens were fighting are completely different. know there are a lot of people who take this seriously, and theyre part of the family. But anyway, Obviously, I have children. The American Revolution was caused by the greed of the British and the thoughts of the enlightened people. There was a mixture of communities throughout the American colonies, there was loyalist communities, and there were revolutionary communities, and they were often in the same city, they were often in the same colony, in secession, there were parts of the south that didnt want to secede. So number one, Al Yuval Levin has said this very well that theres a George Wallace constituency in American politics. Fire the picture, who just called this right. Make a prediction: How important were the Atlantic Revolutions in creating the modern world. Whichever side you choose, well be back tomorrow, and well do this all over again. But, like, we get out, man. Theyre looking at all this toxic mess. A bloody, crowded battle scene shows Haitian revolutionaries fighting for their independence against European colonizers. Or is that just negative partisanship all the way down? But then theres this whole concept of manufactured distrust. Oh, god. I am victimized by the politics here. But that, like, the logistics are too hard. Several men in uniform clap as another is presented with an award. They get in and then they start calling the other people names. So yes, keyboard warriors are not the kind of people who are going to get in the streets. The American and French Revolutions differ more than just location and language. Marjorie Taylor Greene wants a national divorce. The American, French, and Haitian Revolution all had the similar causes of a tyrannical government. It is. Weve most have been talking about the right. Shes not serious. How did the French Revolution impact Saint Domingue? The French, Haitian, and American Revolutions were all sparked from the minds of the colonists, slaves, or lower classes who were treated with inequality by their own governments. Malcolm F. Purinton is a part-time lecturer of world history and the history of modern Europe at Northeastern University and Emmanuel College in Boston. Theres theres pushback that says, well, voters craved this. The American and French Revolution are both remembered in history as two major changes that would shape what we know today. And so you can be a majority. And does it not strike anybody strange that you go to four different media houses and theyre all saying the same thing. Okay. And because when Fox called Arizona, the response was not. Right? Dont trust mail in balloting. First, Enlightenment ideas and ideals inspired all of them. We have seen media scandals. I I do wanna ask you a question when were when were done about whether or not your feelings have changed at all. Thats what she spends all her time doing, and she knits them sweaters and all that stuff. The course of the river was set. Both countries have many differences and similarities, ranging from the individuals fighting these wars to tactics and strategies they used to win. And so we saw this in the Trump era in abundance. By contrast, the British army was a reliable steady force of professionals. Painting of several large sailboats on a stormy sea. Thats doctor Seuss. And the answer is one sentence. Two of the main revolutions were the French Revolution and the Latin American Revolution. Like, on a government building, that was unimaginable. During the French Revolution, there was a period known as the Reign of terror which was a period of extreme violence and brutality against people who did not support the French Revolution. Its what the media does to it. The American colonies did not want to be associated with British anymore they wanted to break away from their mother country, they wanted to be named their own country. From 1790 to 1794, the revolutionaries grew increasingly radical. In response, several men from Boston dressed up as Indigenous Americans and threw tea from British ships into Boston harbor. But, like, you know, when we talk to Dans and we ask them about the Supreme Court, for example Mhmm. And this is happening not just in the sense of you and your neighbor being pushed apart. Republican Party to take on Donald Trump. Alyssa Goldstein Sepinwall is Professor of History at California State University - San Marcos and a specialist in French and Haitian history.In addition to The Abb Grgoire and the French Revolution, her books include Haitian History: New Perspectives (Routledge, 2012) and Slave Revolt on Screen: The Haitian Revolution in Film and Video Games (University Press of Mississippi, 2021). They voted for him twice though, then this to me, I find myself understanding these people and then also thinking that these are the most dangerous people. However, there are crucial differences that led to their respective results and their . Now theres been some gradual lessening on the left as well, but mainly on the right. Intentionally lying. And then close-up the window so that its all hidden. Basically, she thinks that the red states and blue states should each become their own countries. So James Madison wrote federalist number ten, which is the best federalist paper. Thats when were in a very dangerous place. One of the things I fear about the right is the cultural course of the river that is being said. Similar because of what caused both revolutions and different because of the violence that was used in each movement and the outcome from it. Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). The French, Haitian, and American Revolutions were all sparked from the minds of the colonists, slaves, or lower classes who were treated with inequality by their own governments. He joins Sarah to talk about whether (and how) the United States holds together; and the task of rebuilding trust in our institutions. Mhmm. The American Revolution A revolution, in definition, is the overthrow of one government with replacement of another. Thats right. Fire the guy who called this race. Mhmm. He didnt twist the guys arm. I dont get the sense from hearing that that theyre gonna actively oppose Marjorie Taylor. A powerful and popular general named Napoleon Bonaparte soon rose to power and declared himself emperor in 1799. The nation of Haiti formally declared its independence on January 1, 1804. So they wont know about it. Their society was split into two groups. Map shows the area that is now the nation of Haiti. From 1790 to 1794, the French Revolution became increasingly radical. Or do you Beg to Differ?
Oldest Restaurants In Little Italy, Nyc,
2270 Cove Ave, Los Angeles, Ca 90039,
Articles I